Synchronous Condensers

Overview

A synchronous condenser (also called a synchronous capacitor or synchronous compensator) is a conventional solution that has been used for decades for regulating reactive power before there were any power electronics compensation systems.

A synchronous condenser is a Direct Current (DC)-excited synchronous machine (large rotating generators) whose shaft is not attached to any driving equipment. This device provides improved voltage regulation and stability by continuously generating / absorbing adjustable reactive power and improving grid system strength through its inherent short-circuit current contribution. In addition, a flywheel can be added to enhance grid frequency stability by providing additional synchronous inertia. Its purpose is not to convert electric to mechanical power or vice versa, but to make use of the machine’s reactive power control capabilities, short-circuit current contribution and the synchronous inertia. It constitutes an alternative solution to mechanically switched capacitors with damping network (MSCDN) or compensation choke in the power system due to the ability to continuously adjust the reactive power amount in both directions. Its overload capability is also superior to static var compensators (SVCs) or static synchronous compensators (STATCOM) of the same rating.

Synchronous condensers are perfectly suited for controlling the voltage on long transmission lines or in networks with a high penetration of power electronic devices as well as in systems where there is a high risk of “islanding”.

Technology Types

A conventional synchronous condenser is an Alternating Current (AC) synchronous motor that is not attached to any driven equipment. The device can provide continuous reactive power control through field excitation control. Both a static and brushless system may be used. By increasing or decreasing the field current, the system can make the machine generate or absorb reactive power, thereby maintaining voltage stability and regulating reactive power flow in the power system. With proper design, the device can supply multiple times (typically 2–2.5 times) the rated field current and voltage (field forcing capability) for up to 10 seconds, offering dynamic voltage recovery support during depressed grid voltage conditions. Synchronous condensers have traditionally been used at both distribution and transmission voltage levels to improve stability and to maintain voltages within desired limits under changing load conditions and contingency situations. It is worth noting that there are also electrical losses associated with the synchronous condenser, which is the active power the device will consume at a different operating point. These electrical losses directly impact the operating cost of the synchronous condenser plant.

The development of high-temperature superconductivity (HTS) enabled the development of a second type: HTS-based machines, which are smaller, lighter, more efficient and less expensive to manufacture and operate than conventional machines. Advancements in the HTS wire technology have resulted in superconducting electromagnets that can operate at higher temperatures than those made of low-temperature superconductor materials. Consequently, they utilise simpler, less costly and more efficient cooling systems. This makes HTS wires technically feasible and economically viable for condenser applications at power ratings lower than those that can be achieved with the low-temperature superconductor wire.

Figure: Synchronous Condenser [1]
Figure: Synchronous Condenser [1].

Benefits

The benefits of synchronous condensers are listed below:

  • System inertia: inertia is an inherent feature of a synchronous condenser as it is a rotating machine. The benefit of inertia improves voltage “stiffness”, which improves the overall behaviour of the system.
  • Increased short-term overload capability: depending on the type, a synchronous condenser can provide more than two times its rating up to a few seconds, which enhances system support during emergency situations or contingencies.
  • Low voltage ride through: even under extreme low voltage contingencies, it remains connected and provides smooth, reliable operation.
  • Fast response: by using modern excitation and control systems, a synchronous condenser is fast enough to meet dynamic response requirements.
  • Additional short-circuit strength: another feature of a synchronous condenser is that it provides real short-circuit strength to the grid, which improves system stability with weak interconnections and enhances system protection.
  • No harmonics: a synchronous condenser is not a source of harmonics and can even absorb harmonic currents. This feature enables ease of integration into existing networks.

Given the higher levels of losses, mechanical wear and a slower response time compared to power electronic technologies, a preference over synchronous condensers was given to alternatives based on highly dynamic, low-loss and low-maintenance power electronics solutions during the last three decades. As of today, in a world with the massive penetration of renewable energies, synchronous condensers again constitute a robust solution to ensuring system stability in a scenario of the high penetration of renewable generation, and thus play a role in the planning of the future grid (see H2020 Migrate project results on the competition between grid forming and synchronous condensers [1]).

Current Enablers

Typical components of a (complete solution) synchronous condenser are:

  • Stator and rotor with solid integral pole tips;
  • Cooling system (hydrogen, air or water);
  • Excitation system;
  • Lubrication oil supply; and
  • Step-up transformer and auxiliary transformer.

Typical applications of a synchronous condenser include:

  • HVDC: provides short-circuit strength and dynamic reactive power support;
  • Wind and solar: increases short-circuit ratio;
  • Grid support: improves weak Alternating Current (AC) grid performance, voltage support during faults and contingencies, and limits rate of change of frequency (ROCOF); and
  • Regulation: can replace dynamic voltage regulation and inertia from retired units.

R&D Needs

Most of the ongoing developments regard the:

  • Development and implementation of high-temperature superconducting synchronous condensers;
  • Increase in the inertia by coupling with larger flywheels;
  • Minor general improvements in the coupling between synchronous condenser and flywheel, and improvements in bearing e.g., magnetic bearings;
  • Development of a market for use of thermal losses for other customers; and
  • Alignment and standardisation of general requirements for faster deployment of projects.

The technology is in line with milestone “New and optimised control concepts of reactive power” under Mission 3 of the ENTSO-E RDI Roadmap 2024-2034.

TSO Applications

Examples

Location: Brindisi, ItalyYear: 2020
Description: Two synchronous condensers and flywheel are provided to Terna for the Brindisi substation in southern Italy. Each synchronous condenser unit supplies reactive power of up to + 250 / – 125 MVAr and 1750 MWs inertia to support the stability of Italy’s grid.
Design:

These synchronous condensers complement the park of synchronous condensers operated by the Italian TSO. The offer from the manufacturer included the design, civil works, supply, installation and commissioning of the 2 electrical two-pole generators and related equipment (step-up transformers, circuit breakers, auxiliaries and balance of plant, protection and controls systems) as well as the monitoring and diagnostic systems and 20 years of planned maintenance. Each of the generators are equipped with a flywheel to respond to the inertia requirements from Terna.

Results: Both pieces of equipment supply a combined 500 MVAr reactive power and 3500 MWs inertia to help stabilise the grid and support the integration of more renewable energy.
Location: Blackwater station, New Mexico, USYear: 2019
Description: Transmission lines (216 miles) between 362 kV Station (north of Albuquerque) to Blackwater 362 kV Station (near Clovis) enables the exchange of power generated from wind farms between New Mexico and Texas.
Design:

The transmission lines of this length resulted in low short-circuit conditions that were challenging the control and operation of power electronic systems for the high voltage direct current convertor and wind farms located at or near the Blackwater station. Studies revealed that the installation of a synchronous condenser provides the required short circuit capability to facilitate transmission services in Blackwater 362 kV station. The synchronous condenser was selected to provide 959 MVA short circuit power at the 362 kV Blackwater station.

Results: The installation of the synchronous condenser maintains acceptable system performance by increasing the short-circuit ratio and providing voltage support during faults and contingencies, thereby enabling the transmission of power in New Mexico.
Location: Oberottmarshausen, Bavaria, GermanyYear: 2018
Description: The nuclear power plant in Gundremmingen with a 1.34 GW capacity was shut down to enforce the Atomic Energy Act. Therefore, measures to ensure grid stability with respect to inertia and reactive power compensation were required.
Design:

A synchronous condenser offered a wide reactive power + 340 to – 170 MVAr with loss optimised and life-time optimised operation. The solution ensured grid stability during voltage fluctuations.

Results: A synchronous condenser was incorporated to provide a wide range of reactive power capability for operating under ambient temperature conditions in Oberottmarshausen.
Location: Scotland, United KingdomYear: 2017
Description: A partnership between the UK Utility, the System Operator, and academic institutions to demonstrate a sustainable design and operational control of a synchronous condenser with an innovative coordinated control system combined with a STATCOM flexible AC transmission system device. The project was awarded a budget of £17.64 m through the UK’s Network Innovation Competition (NIC) in 2016.
Design:

Synchronous condenser with innovative coordinated control system combined with a STATCOM flexible AC transmission system device.

Results: The provision of an efficient and composite solution that will enhance system stability and security while maintaining power quality, resulting in minimising the risks of power outages and delivering significant benefits to UK customers.
Location: Bjæverskov, Fraugde and Herslev substations (Denmark)Year: 2015
Description: Denmark is one of the few countries to include a large share of wind energy in its energy mix, which is why the country requires synchronous condenser solutions to help stabilise its electricity transmission system and support higher wind power generation.
Design:

The scope of delivery for the synchronous condenser solutions included a synchronous generator with brushless excitation, a generator step-up transformer and the electrical auxiliary systems, such as control and safety systems, voltage regulators and startup systems. Each synchronous condenser solution can deliver more than 900 MVA of short-circuit power and + 215 / –  150 MVAr of reactive power. The startup time is designed so that the generators can reach up to 3,000 rpm within 10 minutes and be synchronised with the transmission grid. There is a minimum availability of 98%. They feature high efficiency, low noise emissions, and low installation and commissioning costs.

Results: Bjæverskov substation 250 MVAr synchronous condenser solution started operating in The Fraugde and Herslev substations synchronous condenser solution is capable of delivering more than 900 MVA of short-circuit power and +150 / – 75 MVAr of reactive power. Trial operation as of August 2014.
Location: Codrongianos, ItalyYear: 2014 (year of connection to the grid)
Description: 2 × 250 MVAr synchronous condensers for stabilising the Sardinian grid. Speed: 3000 rpm. Voltage: 19 kV.
Design:

Synchronous condensers aim to allow a safer and enhanced utilisation of the Sardinian High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) links. The two synchronous condensers present innovative differences with respect to traditional ones: round rotor design (better cost / Mvar ratio), two poles design to reduce weight and cost, air-to-water cooling to simplify maintenance, fast static starting system (< 15 minutes), adiabatic cooling system for the primary water circuit, 200% overload capability (10 seconds), completely unmanned operation from the remote control centre. Total losses are estimated at 1.15%.

Results: Safer and enhanced utilisation of the Sardinian HVDC links.
Location: Hesse, GermanyYear: 2013
Description: After the governmental decision to shut down the nuclear power plants in Germany following the Fukushima incident, one of the generating units of the 2.5 GW Biblis nuclear power plant was converted into a rotating synchronous condenser.
Design:

A 14 MW medium voltage startup converter was set up for generator startup. This was connected to a new 18.3 MVA transformer, which subsequently transforms its output voltage to the generator terminal voltage of 27 kV via a further 17 MVA transformer. With a gas-insulated 30 kV medium voltage switchgear, the new system was connected to the generator via the generator terminal lead.

Results: The newly converted condenser regulates the reactive power from – 400 to + 900 MVAr, which is made available to grid operator Amprion in situations of low or high voltage.

Technology Readiness Level The TRL has been assigned to reflect the European state of the art for TSOs, following the guidelines available here.

Min. TRL 3 Max. TRL 9
123456789
    TRL 9 for conventional synchronous condensers.

      TRL 3 to 5 for a high-temperature superconductive synchronous condenser in extra high voltage grid.

References and further reading

  1. Synchronous Condenser: Design, Working, Phasor Diagram & Its Applications

  2. H2020 MIGRATE, “The MIGRATE project website downloads and brochure ‘The Massive InteGRATion of power Electronic devices.’”, Cordis.europa.eu.

  3. ABB, “Synchronous condensers for reactive power compensation”.

  4. GE, “Synchronous condenser systems”, gevernova.com.

  5. WEG, “Synchronous condensers”, Weg.net.

  6. SP Energy Networks, “Phoenix – System Security and Synchronous Condenser”, Spenergynetworks.co.uk.

  7. Siemens, “The stable way. Synchronous condenser solutions”, Siemens-energy.com.

  8. T. Abdulahovic and S. TelekChalmers, “University of Technology. Modeling and Comparison of SC and SVC”, Chalmers University of Technology.

  9. Siemens, “Renaissance of a classic – the synchronous condenser”. Ansaldo Energia, “Brochure on Synchronous Condenser”.

  10. S. Kalsi, D. Madura and M. Ross, “Performance of Superconductor Dynamic Synchronous Condenser on an Electric Grid”, presented at Transmission and Distribution Conference and Exhibition: Asia and Pacific, 2005 IEEE/PES, Feb. 2005.

  11. F. O. Igbinovia, G. Fhandi, Z. Muller and J. Tlusty, “IEEE Reputation of the Synchronous Condenser Technology in Modern Power Grid”, presented at IEEE International Conference on Power System Technology, Nov. 2018.

  12. F. Palone and M. Rebolini, “Synchronous condensers in multi-infeed HVDC systems”, presented at AEIT/CIGRE HVDC Transmission Workshop at Milan, May 2014.

GET THE MOST POWERFUL NEWSLETTER IN BRUSSELS